In comparison to theory x, theory y incorporates a pseudo. Theory x and theory y type leadership behavior and its. According to theory x, power and authority should be centralized while at the same time having a hierarchy or chain of command upon which instructions flow whereas. Generation z are those people born between 1995 and 2010, roughly. Theory x, theory y, and theory z introduction to business. Douglas mcgregors theory x vs theory y lucidchart blog. Comparison and contrast on theory xy and z writework. Mcgregor 1960 famously argued that there are two types of managers. Both of these theories begin with the premise that managements role is to assemble the factors of production, including people, for the economic benefit of the firm.
He was a strong supporter of theories x and y, and he put theory y that people want to work, achieve and take responsibility into practice in a californian electronics factory. His work is based upon maslows hierarchy of needs, where he grouped the hiera. Comparison and contrast on theory xy and z douglas mcgregor suggested that there are two different ways in which we can look at workers attitudes toward work. Explanation of fourteen points of management by edward deming. All about mcgregors theory x and theory y 12manage.
Mcgregors xy theory is a natural rule for managing people. Theory z is a name for various theories of human motivation built on douglas mcgregors theory x and theory y. Critically evaluate mcgregors theroy x and theory y free. Theory x and theory y in 1960, douglas mcgregor formulated theory x and theory y suggesting two aspects of human behaviour at work, or in other words, two different views of individuals employees. Douglas mcgregor, an american social psychologist, proposed his famous x y theory in his 1960 book the human side of enterprise.
Theory z, however, advocates a combination of all best attributes of theory y and modern japanese management principles, which place a large amount of freedom and trust with workers, and assumes that workers have a strong loyalty and interest in teamworking and the. Comparative analysis of theory x, theory y, theory z, and theory. Comparative analysis of theory x, theory y, theory z, and theory a for managing people and performance article pdf available june 2016 with 8,355 reads how we measure reads. The relationship between mcgregors xy theory management. In 1960, douglas mcgregor formulated theory x and theory y suggesting two aspects of human behaviour at work, or in other words, two different views of individuals employees. Aug 16, 2016 organizational behaviour in the context of people management consists of several theories in which theory x, theory y, theory z are the newly introduced. The purpose of this paper is to apply mcgregors theory x and theory y to study teacher motivation in higher education. Humans inherently dislike working and will try to avoid it if they can. Difference between theory x and theory y with comparison. Jul 11, 2017 the challenge of being a theory y manager.
In this article, we are going to talk about the major differences between theory x and theory y. Theory x and theory y was an idea devised by douglas mcgregor in his. Theory into practice abraham maslow viewed mcgregor as a mentor. With the onslaught of b2b social media, and the break down of formal business approach, business. Most managers will likely use a mixture of theory x and theory y. Theory x assumptions believe that workers must be controlled and threatened with punishment allio, 2009. It has generated wide ranging and lasting interest in the field of motivation. Theory xy douglas mcgregor and theory z william ouichi theory x an authoritarian style of management the average worker dislikes work. You may, however, find that you naturally favor one over the other. Theories x, y and various versions of z have been used in human resource management, organizational behavior, organizational communication and. Differences between theory x and theory y difference between. Essay on theory x and theory y 1295 words bartleby.
His work is based upon maslows hierarchy of needs, where he grouped the hierarchy into lowerorder needs theory x and higherorder needs theory y. Mcgregors work was rooted in motivation theory alongside the works of abraham maslow, who created the hierarchy of needs. You might, for instance, have a tendency to micromanage or, conversely, you may prefer to take a more handsoff approach. Pdf theory x and theory y type leadership behavior and. Difference between theory x and theory y compare the. Mcgregors theory x and theory y are theories about human behavior and motivation in the organization that was published in 1960 by douglas mcgregor. Theory y managers gravitate towards relating to the worker on a more personal level, as opposed to a more conductive and teachingbased relationship. Theory x and theory y describe two views of people at work and may be used to describe two opposing management styles. Theory x and theory y are theories of human work motivation and management. A boss can be viewed as taking the theory x approach, while a leader takes the theory y approach. Deming went to japan just after the war to help set up. Mcgregors ideas suggest that there are two fundamental approaches to managing people.
Many years ago a professor named douglas mcgregor dubbed these perspectives theory x and theory y. May 02, 2017 theory x and theory y were introduced in 1960 by douglas mcgregor, an american social psychologist in his book the human side of enterprise. Each of these views, which mcgregor called theory x and theory y, has implications for management. Theory x and theory y, developed by douglas mcgregor, grew out of opposition towards classical management methods. This article describes the theory x and theory y of douglas mcgregor. Developed in the 1960s by douglas mcgregor in his book, the human side of enterprise, theory x and theory y allocate the job of management into two styles. Organizational behaviour in the context of people management consists of several theories in which theory x, theory y, theory z are the newly introduced. He summarized the findings of the hawthorn experiment by introducing both theory x and theory y. Though these theories are very basic in nature, they provide a platform for future generations of management theorists and practitioners to understand the changing dynamics of human behavior. In combination, both approaches are referred to as theory xy. In 1960, douglas mcgregor developed a leadership theory mcgregor theory x and theory y about organization and management in which he.
In contrast to the principles of conventional management mentioned as theory x, the advocated theory y illuminated a cluster of new or redefined concepts such as selffulfilling prophecy and responsibility. In the 1960s, douglas murray mcgregor, a famous mit professor of management wrote a book named the human side of enterprise in which he analyzed the various behaviors of professionals at work. While theory y might help to explain the findings in the two laboratories, we clearly need something other than theory x or y assumptions to explain the findings in the plants. Pdf comparative analysis of theory x, theory y, theory z. Theory x assumes that people dislike work and will. The following ideas have been put forward to attract and retain this next. Theory x is the view that traditional management has taken towards the workforce. It is important to note that both theory x and theory y are based on the argument that there are specific approaches to managing.
Theory x and y were created and developed by douglas mcgregor in the 1960s. Theory z management style which thinks workers will be participating in the decisions of the company to a great degree. This theory divides workers and managers in the organization in two typical groups according to how managers lead their subordinates and respectively how subordinates behave character of the. Equally so, there is little research on generational theory and how this relates to. Beyond this point, the two theories of management diverge. Theory xy douglas mcgregor and theory z william ouichi. The democratic approach of theory y makes people feel comfortable as a result of which they commit themselves wholeheartedly to the organization. Douglas mcgregor wrote about theory x and theory y in the late 1950s and early 1960s.
Get an answer for compare the theory x, theory y, and theory z assumptions of human relations. People view work as being as natural as play and rest. The x y theory questionnaire page 1 of 2 indicates whether the situation and management style is the x or y style. The idea that a managers attitude has an impact on employee motivation was originally proposed by douglas mcgregor, a management professor at the massachusetts institute of technology during the 1950s and 1960s. Professor douglas mcgregor highlighted that there is a significant relationship between motivation and leadership among people. Aug 21, 2015 the theory x and theory y are not based on a single truth. Theory x management style generally get poor results compare with managers use theory y, which produces better performance and results, and allows people to grow and develop. Application of theory x and y in classroom management by. Copyright 2017, scholarly research journal for interdisciplinary. This is one of the most famous motivational theories in management. Pdf the impact of theory x, theory y and theory z on. Theory z suggests that large complex organisations are human systems and their effectiveness depends on the.
Douglas mcgregor, an american social psychologist, proposed his famous theory x and theory y models in his book the human side of enterprise 1960. Pdf theory x and theory y type leadership behavior and its. Theory xy remains central to organizational development, and to. Urwicks theory z much after the propositions of theories x and y by mcgregor, the three theorists lyndall fowner urwick march 3, 1891 dec. Mcgregor, with his theory x and theory y, and ouchi, with the notion of a. The purpose of this study is to find the impact of theory x, theory y and theory z on research performance of foundation university members in turkey on the number of articles published in science citation index and social science citation index. As far as the upper limit is concerned, infinity is always correct. You seem to have switched x and y between the posts, so i am not sure how you are defining z. X and consider using the techniques suggested by theory y. And, just like your algebra class, x and y dont work totally independently, although you can manage in a style that is mostly a theory x or theory y management style. Theory x says that the average human being is lazy and selfcentred, lacks ambition, dislikes change, and longs to be told what to do. Ouchis theory first appeared in his 1981 book, theory z. How american management can meet the japanese challenge.
A comparison and contrast of these two theorists will be presented, which will. Theory x and theory y type leadership behavior and its impact. Theory x managers and theory y managers often see their perceptions of people confirmed. They were created by douglas mcgregor while he was working at the mit sloan school of management in the 1950s, and developed further in the 1960s.
Comparison of theories x and y, urwicks theory z, history of. Difference between theory x and theory y with comparison chart. Ouchi born in 1943 propounded the third theory labelled as z. It helped to crystallise and put into right perspective the findings of the hawthorne experiments. Difference between theory x and theory y of motivation and. Pdf organizational behaviour in the context of people management consists of several theories in which theory x, theory y,theory z are the. Mcgregor developed a philosophical view of humankind with his theory x and theory y in 1960. Theory x and theory y, given by mcgregor, are explained below with the main assumptions of each theory. Edwards deming w edwards deming was an american statistician who is associated with the rise of japan as a manufacturing nation, and with the invention of total quality management tqm.
Theory x and theory y, introduced in the book and are known for management and human motivation. On the other extreme, theory y is diametrically opposite to theory x which shows the modern and dynamic approach to individuals and relies on the assumptions that are practical in nature. Theory x and theory y team management training from. Therefore most people must be motivated by forcedbribed with the threat of punishment or a reward to produce effort and work towards organizational objectives. Theory x can benefit a work place that utilizes an assembly line or manual labor. Suppose x 0, x 1 are consecutive zeros of u 1 x, and assume thatx 0 x 1. Theory x says that the average human being is lazy and selfcentred, lacks ambition, dislikes change, and longs to. In 1943, abraham maslow proposed a simple psychological theory on human needs as they relate to motivation and the order in which they progress. A comparative analysis of entrepreneurial intent eleanor rosalind brown 2960 2816. As a result, theory y followers may have a better relationship with their boss, creating a healthier atmosphere in the workplace.
However because the random variables are nonnegative, one of the fs may be 0 past some point, so the integral doesnt need to go any further. Many theorists support that mcgregors theory considers the field of management from a new angle, indicating a strong influential value. Theory x and theory y to pick the best management style. The three prior studies that have made this distinction were recently conducted solely to develop constructvalid measures of both. Designmethodologyapproach an empirical study was conducted through. Theory x managers assume that workers are lazy, will avoid responsibility, and prefer to just get by. The result was theory za development beyond theory x and theory y that blended the best of eastern and western management practices.
Jul 08, 2017 on the other extreme, theory y is diametrically opposite to theory x which shows the modern and dynamic approach to individuals and relies on the assumptions that are practical in nature. In his 1960 book, the human side of enterprise, mcgregor proposed two theories by which managers perceive and address. William ouchi developed theory z after making a comparative study of japanese and american management practices. Douglas mcgregors theory x and theory y of motivation. In his 1960 book, the human side of enterprise, mcgregor proposed two theories by which managers perceive and address employee motivation. Theory x vs theory y managers because employees have historically been given a flat exchange of time and energy for income, workplace incentives have often been rooted in a fear of loss of employment, in earning potential from extra productivity, or in acquiescing to managerial dominance for promotion. Generation z also often referred to as generation m or as postmillennials the people who form generation z do a lot of things differently to the babyboomers, generation x or generation y. Theory x and theory y are still referred to commonly in the field of management and motivation, and whilst more recent studies have questioned the rigidity of the model, mcgregors x y theory remains a valid basic principle from which to develop positive management. After reading you will understand the background and the practical basics of these leadership styles what is theory x and theory y. The average human being has an inherent dislike of work and will avoid it if possible. Classical management theorists, such as fredrick taylor, focused on scientific training and efficiency and did not account for personal and behavioral issues, such as management styles or job satisfaction.
Theories x, y and various versions of z have been used in human resource management, organizational behavior, organizational communication and organizational development. Jun 25, 2019 developed in the 1960s by douglas mcgregor in his book, the human side of enterprise, theory x and theory y allocate the job of management into two styles. Many organisations are now taking the enlightened view of theory y. Douglas mcgregor suggested that there are two different ways in which we can look at workers attitudes toward work. Theory y maintains that human beings are active rather than passive shapers of. In comparison to theory x, theory y adds more of a democratic and free feel in the. Difference between theory x and theory y of motivation and its critical appraisal. The impact of theory x, theory y and theory z on research. Comparative analysis of theory x, theory y, theory z, and. In comparison to theory x, theory y incorporates a pseudodemocratic environment to the workforce. Theory z suggests that large complex organisations are human systems and their effectiveness depends on the quality of humanism used.
1167 1398 225 1067 170 293 636 1197 161 944 306 341 773 1152 1351 1282 1460 27 1546 911 1199 1020 1436 581 986 1177 462 178 328 788 377 799 916 360